About

In-house lawyers' limited AI skills keep them from demanding it of outside law firms

Published
Score
21

Why it matters

Stephen Embry's Above the Law column, published November 18, 2026, argues that many corporate legal teams know little more about AI than their outside firms do, and that this gap undermines their ability to negotiate where AI should cut fees without sacrificing quality. The column cites a survey finding that 83% of in-house lawyers cannot measure AI's return on investment. It also reports that 95% expect outside counsel to use AI effectively, and 92% expect lower rates when firms do, an expectation that is largely unmet.

The column's figures echo earlier surveys. An ACC and Everlaw study found 67% of in-house lawyers use generative AI, up from 38% the prior year, yet 80% do not require or encourage outside counsel to do the same. A Thomson Reuters analysis found 54% of corporate respondents think outside firms should use AI, but fewer than 20% mandate it through guidelines or RFPs. An ACC report from September 2026 put in-house AI use at 85% of legal departments. The column is an opinion piece, and its survey numbers come from the sources it cites, not from independent reporting. The attribution for the claim that 64% of in-house teams expect to depend less on outside counsel is also unclear, as the analysts behind it are not named.

For attorneys, the practical signal is that clients are building internal AI capacity and may soon press firms for AI-based fee reductions. A Legal Business and Thomson Reuters survey of more than 250 senior UK and European in-house lawyers, published November 11, 2026, found 82% are already implementing generative AI within their teams. Firms should expect requests to explain where AI is used and how it affects billing. Watch for AI requirements showing up in outside counsel guidelines and RFPs, which are still rare but are the mechanism most likely to turn expectations into contract terms.

Sources

mail Subscribe to Artificial Intelligence email updates

Primary sources. No fluff. Straight to your inbox.

Also on LawSnap