Several points remain unsettled. The Variety Media v. Superior Court appeal is still pending, and the retroactive provision applies regardless of how that case is decided. Commentators note the bill does not reach related claims under CIPA sections 631 and 632, and they expect plaintiffs to recast allegations under those sections. How courts will apply the retroactive provision to specific pending cases has not yet been tested. Some commentators argue further CIPA reform is still needed.
Attorneys with pending pen register claims should check whether each filing falls within the two-year lookback window, since that determines whether the change affects the case. Businesses using cookies, pixels and similar tools face less exposure under this provision, but they should not treat the issue as closed. The Attorney General and the California Privacy Protection Agency can still pursue website-tracking practices, and sections 631 and 632 remain available to plaintiffs. Firms that built high-volume demand-letter practices around section 638.51 will need to reassess their pipelines before the January 1 effective date.