About

Richards Layton Lawyer Fined $2,500 Over AI-Error Brief; Firm Spared Sanctions

Published
Score
21

Why it matters

Delaware Vice Chancellor Lori W. Will of the Court of Chancery sanctioned Richard Rollo, a director at Richards Layton & Finger, $2,500 on November 13, 2026, for signing a brief that contained AI-generated errors. The brief was filed in January in Kidd v. Leiske et al. (C.A. No. 2025-0426), a legal fee advancement dispute involving Hard Yaka Ventures. After opposing counsel alleged the brief contained fictitious citations, fabricated quotations, and hallucinated legal propositions, the firm admitted in a letter that it used "a generative artificial intelligence tool" to revise the brief and failed to verify the citations, blaming a paralegal's review. Will declined to sanction the firm, citing its "commendable efforts to prevent GenAI misuse," but found Rollo's conduct lacking. She said delegation to junior lawyers and paralegals is acceptable, but the signing attorney keeps a nondelegable duty to ensure accuracy.

The reporting does not explain how the court resolved the firm's inconsistent account of the brief's preparation, which the firm had asked the court to consider before any sanction decision. The filing of the corrected answering brief is confirmed, but the reporting does not describe its contents or any changes beyond the citations. Whether Rollo or the firm will appeal has not been reported.

For attorneys, the ruling draws a line between individual and firm exposure. A detailed AI policy and mandatory ethics training did not shield the signing lawyer, because Will noted Rollo failed to verify the brief "despite his law firm's comprehensive GenAI policy and mandatory ethics training." She also said generative AI use is "neither forbidden nor inherently problematic," so the issue is verification, not use. Firms should review whether their citation-checking steps cover AI-edited text and whether signing attorneys know they cannot rely on a paralegal's review alone.

Sources

mail Subscribe to Law And Technology email updates

Primary sources. No fluff. Straight to your inbox.

Also on LawSnap