About

Perplexity Retreats From Keeping Proskauer as Counsel in Reddit Data-Scraping Suit

Published
Score
18

Why it matters

Perplexity AI Inc. has dropped its effort to keep Proskauer Rose LLP as its defense counsel in Reddit Inc.'s data-scraping lawsuit, after Reddit objected to the firm's earlier work for the platform. Reddit sued Perplexity in federal court in New York, accusing it and three other companies of unlawfully scraping Reddit data to train Perplexity's AI-based search engine. The others are Lithuania-based Oxylabs, Russia-based AWMProxy, and Texas-based SerpApi. Reddit filed a similar suit against Anthropic in June. Perplexity denies the copyright infringement claims. The disqualification fight began in the fall. Reddit asked a federal judge in Manhattan to remove Proskauer, arguing that its past representation of Reddit in a whistleblower case created a conflict. That case was brought by former employee Jutta Williams, who said she was fired after raising privacy and licensing concerns. Reddit says the firm learned confidential details of its deals with Google and OpenAI. Proskauer argues the earlier matter was an employment dispute, separate from the scraping claims. As recently as October, Proskauer and Perplexity were asking the court to let the firm stay on the case.

The withdrawal was not the product of a court ruling, so the court has not decided whether Proskauer had a conflict. The research does not include the withdrawal filing itself, so its terms and any stated reasons are not yet public. The case's assigned judge, reported as Judge Engelmayer, comes from a single filing summary and has not been verified against the docket. The filings in the underlying scraping dispute, including the claims against Oxylabs, AWMProxy, and SerpApi, are not covered here.

For litigators, the practical lesson is that former-client conflicts can reshape AI litigation staffing late in a case, even without a ruling. Any firm that has advised a platform on data licensing or employee disputes should check its conflicts history before taking on an opposing AI company. The case also fits Reddit's broader strategy of pairing licensing deals, including its existing arrangements with Google and others, with enforcement against AI firms that scrape its content. Watch for a substitute counsel filing from Perplexity and any further motions in the Anthropic matter.

Sources

mail Subscribe to Intellectual Property email updates

Primary sources. No fluff. Straight to your inbox.

Also on LawSnap