About

Bracewell video warns litigators that expert witnesses' AI chat logs can be pulled in discovery

Published
Score
30

Why it matters

Expert witnesses' chatbot transcripts can reveal their reasoning, premises, and working assumptions, and opposing counsel can use them in discovery and cross-examination. That is the argument David A. Shargel of Bracewell LLP makes in a Bracewell Explains video, republished on NatLawReview. The video builds on Bracewell's earlier written analysis, which describes a deposition where opposing counsel learned of an expert's AI use and obtained more than 300 pages of ChatGPT conversations. The video urges organizations that retain experts to set rules on AI use, disclosure, record preservation, and independent checking before an engagement begins.

Federal courts have not settled how far expert AI prompts are discoverable. In Conservation Law Foundation v. Shell Oil, in the District of Connecticut, Magistrate Judge Thomas Farrish ordered a plaintiff to produce the generative AI prompts its expert used, treating them as discoverable methodology. The court stayed that order on June 3, 2026, after the plaintiff challenged it. In Villanueva v. Las Vegas Metropolitan Police Department, a District of Nevada judge ruled on September 29, 2026 that the expert's prompts and drafts were protected, but ordered production of AI-generated case summaries the expert had considered. Whether the Shell stay holds and how the courts will reconcile these approaches remain open.

Attorneys should address AI in expert retention agreements now. Bracewell recommends requiring experts to disclose the AI tools they use, obtain counsel's approval before using them, and verify AI output against the facts. Counsel should also raise expert AI use at Rule 26(f) conferences. Bracewell suggests considering a Rule 29 stipulation making expert AI use non-discoverable, though it notes parties may be reluctant to give up that line of questioning. Watch the Shell stay and any further district or appellate rulings on the prompts-versus-outputs line the Villanueva court drew.

Sources

mail Subscribe to Law And Technology email updates

Primary sources. No fluff. Straight to your inbox.

Also on LawSnap