Pro hac vice in S.D. Fla. →
judge console · S.D. Fla.
S.D. Fla. · Judge Elfenbein · Practice Guide

Hon. Marty Fulgueira Elfenbein

All local rules for S.D. Fla., integrated with this judge's published requirements.

Know Before You Go
👤 Judge Elfenbein — practice notes
  • - Counsel shall not call chambers to seek an immediate ruling during a deposition.
  • - FLSA cases: exempt from settlement pre-conference memorandum requirement (Judge Elfenbein's page expressly exempts FLSA cases; standard cases must submit a pre-conference, confidential settlement memorandum).
  • - Settlement conference in-person required (Zoom only for truly extraordinary circumstances).
  • - Settlement start time generally 9 a.m., continue until at least 12 p.m.
Get updates when Judge Elfenbein's procedures change
Before You File
Ex parte applications
🏛 S.D. Fla. local rule

(d) Procedure for Filing Ex Parte. A party submitting an ex parte filing shall: (1) Include the words “ex parte” in the title of the motion and explain the reasons for ex parte treatment. Upon submission, unless the Court directs otherwise the ex-parte filing will be restricted from public view and the docket text appearing on the public docket will reflect only that a restricted filing has been made. Counsel need not serve motions filed ex parte and related documents unless and until the Court so orders. S.D. Fla. L.R. 5.4(d)(1) ↗

Contacting chambers
👤 Judge Elfenbein — standing order

Counsel may contact chambers, including the courtroom deputy and/or the law clerks, about procedures specific to Judge Elfenbein and for scheduling hearings. Chambers will not answer questions regarding substantive matters pertaining to the case or procedures that the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure and/or the Local Rules for the Southern District of Florida otherwise govern. Likewise, chambers will not provide advice on how to handle legal questions. When contacting chambers, please have all counsel of record or pro se parties, as applicable, on the telephone call and be ready to provide the case number and presiding Judge so that we may better assist you. Absent a true emergency, counsel of record shall not contact chambers to ask questions concerning the status of pending matters. Except for any confidential statements submitted pursuant to the Court's Order Scheduling Settlement Conference, any communications via email should copy all counsel of record or any pro se parties, as applicable. Any proposed orders or scheduling matters can be communicated via email to Elfenbein@flsd.uscourts.gov

Settlement notification
👤 Judge Elfenbein — standing order

Settlement conferences generally start at 9 a.m. and continue until at least 12 p.m. The Court requires in-person appearances of parties with full authority to resolve the case. Counsel may move for Zoom appearances if there are truly extraordinary circumstances. Except for cases filed under the Fair Labor Standards Act, the Court requires each party to submit a pre-conference, confidential settlement memorandum. Additional details will be outlined in the Court's Order Scheduling Settlement Conference.

Drafting the Motion
Length limits — motion, opposition, reply
🏛 S.D. Fla. local rule
Motion

(2) Length. Absent prior permission of the Court, neither a motion and its incorporated memorandum of law nor the opposing memorandum of law shall exceed twenty (20) pages; a reply memorandum shall not exceed ten (10) pages. S.D. Fla. L.R. 7.1(c)(2) ↗

Opposition

(2) Length. Absent prior permission of the Court, neither a motion and its incorporated memorandum of law nor the opposing memorandum of law shall exceed twenty (20) pages; a reply memorandum shall not exceed ten (10) pages. S.D. Fla. L.R. 7.1(c)(2) ↗

Reply

(2) Length. Absent prior permission of the Court, neither a motion and its incorporated memorandum of law nor the opposing memorandum of law shall exceed twenty (20) pages; a reply memorandum shall not exceed ten (10) pages. S.D. Fla. L.R. 7.1(c)(2) ↗

Filing & Scheduling
Briefing schedule & hearing date
🏛 S.D. Fla. local rule
Notice period

(1) Requirements and Timing. For all motions, except motions served with the summons and complaint, each party opposing a motion shall file and serve an opposing memorandum of law no later than fourteen (14) days after service of the motion. Failure to do so may be deemed sufficient cause for granting the motion by default. The movant may, within seven (7) days after service of an opposing memorandum of law, file and serve a reply memorandum in support of the motion, which reply memorandum shall be strictly limited to rebuttal of matters raised in the memorandum in opposition without reargument of matters covered in the movant’s initial memorandum of law. S.D. Fla. L.R. 7.1(c)(1) ↗

Hearing days

(b) Hearings. (1) No hearing will be held on motions unless set by the Court. S.D. Fla. L.R. 7.1(b)(1) ↗

Proposed orders
🏛 S.D. Fla. local rule

(a) Filing. (1) Every motion when filed and served shall incorporate a memorandum of law citing supporting authorities, except that the following motions need not incorporate a memorandum: (A) petition for writ of habeas corpus ad testificandum or ad prosequendum; (B) motion for out-of-state process; (C) motion for order of publication for process; (D) application for default; (E) motion for judgment upon default; (F) motion to withdraw or substitute counsel; (G) motion for continuance, provided the good cause supporting it is set forth in the motion and affidavit required by Local Rule 7.6; (H) motion for confirmation of sale; (I) motion to withdraw or substitute exhibits; (J) motion for extensions of time providing the good cause supporting it is set forth in the motion; (K) motion for refund of bond, provided the good cause supporting it is set forth in the motion; (L) application for leave to proceed in forma pauperis; (M) motion for admission pro hac vice; and (N) motion for court approval of a stipulation between any parties. (2) Those motions listed in (a)(1) above, as well as any motion seeking emergency or ex parte relief or a temporary restraining order, shall be accompanied by a proposed order that is filed and served submitted via e-mail to the Court as prescribed by Section 3I(6) of the CM/ECF Administrative Procedures. S.D. Fla. L.R. 7.1(a)(1)-(2) ↗

Filing under seal
👤 Judge Elfenbein — standing order

Silent on under_seal_requirements.

The Hearing
Oral argument
🏛 S.D. Fla. local rule

(2) A party who desires oral argument or a hearing of any motion shall request it within the motion or opposing memorandum in a separate section titled “request for hearing.” The request shall set forth in detail the reasons why a hearing is desired and would be helpful to the Court and shall estimate the time required for argument. The Court in its discretion may grant or deny a hearing as requested, upon consideration of both the request and any response thereto by an opposing party. S.D. Fla. L.R. 7.1(b)(2) ↗

Discovery
Discovery referral procedure
🏛 S.D. Fla. local rule

(3) Discovery motions may be referred to and heard by a United States Magistrate Judge. S.D. Fla. L.R. 7.1(b)(3) ↗

Discovery dispute procedure
👤 Judge Elfenbein — standing order

Written discovery motions are not permitted without leave of Court. Counsel should confer first and, if Court intervention is necessary, contact chambers to schedule a hearing. Personal conference, in person or by telephone, is required unless the opposing party or counsel refuses to confer, in which case the moving party should advise the Court in the notice of discovery hearing of such good faith efforts to confer and the opposing party or counsel's refusal. The Court expects parties and their counsel to be professional and cooperative in all discovery matters. Counsel shall not call chambers to seek an immediate ruling to address any dispute that arises during a deposition.

More from Judge Elfenbein’s procedures
👤 Judge Elfenbein — standing order
Adjournment extension procedure

Silent on adjournment_extension_procedure. Source ↗

Courtesy copies details

Silent on courtesy_copies_details. Source ↗

Initial conference timing

Silent on initial_conference_timing. Source ↗

Motion word page limits

Silent on motion_word_page_limits. Source ↗

Oral argument procedure

Silent on oral_argument_procedure. Source ↗

Pre motion procedure

In cases where the presiding District Judge refers all pretrial discovery matters to Judge Elfenbein, the Court will issue a standing discovery order with specific discovery procedures for use in the event of a discovery dispute. Written discovery motions are not permitted without leave of Court. Counsel should confer first and, if Court intervention is necessary, contact chambers to schedule a hearing. Source ↗

content assembled from published local rules & standing orders · click any section in the rail for the full treatment
Get updates on Judge Elfenbein's procedures
Standing order changes, new key traps, and S.D. Fla. practice intelligence.