When a defendant moves to strike a Civil Code § 3294 prayer for punitive damages, courts struck the punitive allegations at least in part in 408 of 735 rulings. In the other 327, the court denied the motion and the punitive damages claim survived.


| If you are | Look at |
|---|---|
| Pleading punitive damages | Issues 1 to 4 |
| Suing a company | Issue 2 (managing agent) |
| Suing a health care provider or religious corporation | Issue 4 (gatekeeping) |
| Moving to strike | The "Losing version" column of issues 1 to 4 |
Four issues that decided the motion: the losing and winning version of each
We coded the reason each court gave for its ruling. These are the courts' own stated reasons, not our view of the pleading. Each row pairs the version of an issue that lost with the version that won. The counts in a row use different groups of rulings, so read each one on its own terms.
| Issue | Losing version | Winning version |
|---|---|---|
| 1. How was malice, oppression or fraud pleaded? | Where the court cited conclusory labels ("Malicious, oppressive, despicable," with no facts behind it): struck at least in part in 214 of 215. Case No. 26NWCV00226 (Los Angeles County Superior Court), a DUI collision where the complaint alleged driving over the limit plus malice language: "Accordingly, Defendant's motion to strike is GRANTED with 30 days LEAVE TO AMEND." | Where the court cited specific facts (what the defendant knew and what it did): the punitive damages claim survived in 288 of 311 (the other 23 were struck in part). Case No. 26STCV06903 (Los Angeles County Superior Court), a habitability case with a knowing failure to abate after repeated notice: "Therefore, the complaint properly prays for punitive damages." |
| 2. Company defendant: was the conduct tied to management? | Where the court cited the managing-agent requirement (no officer, director or managing agent tied to the conduct): struck at least in part in 73 of 77 (47 with leave, 13 without, 13 in part). Case No. 25STCV10453 (Los Angeles County Superior Court): "Plaintiff's complaint does not allege acts made by the officers, directors, or managing agents of 502 Harvard. Without this, Plaintiff has not adequately pled punitive damages for a corporate defendant." | In the same 77 rulings, where the court found ratification adequately pled: the claim survived in 4 of 77. Case No. 25TRCV01816 (Los Angeles County Superior Court): the amended complaint identified a customer-service manager who authorized a pretextual claim denial, and the court held "Plaintiff has alleged ratification. Therefore, the Court denies the Motion to Strike." |
| 3. Can the claim carry punitive damages at all? | Where the court cited negligence or contract claims only: struck in 49 of 49 (21 without leave). Case No. 25STCV18185 (Los Angeles County Superior Court): faulty gates and unanswered complaints were, at most, negligence. The court granted the motion "WITHOUT LEAVE TO AMEND." | Where the court cited an intentional tort that carries punitive damages on its own (usually fraud): the claim survived in 26 of 27. |
| 4. Health care provider or religious corporation: was the court order obtained (Code of Civil Procedure §§ 425.13 and 425.14)? | Where the court cited a missing § 425.13 or § 425.14 order: struck in 21 of 21 (15 without leave). In Case No. 25CHCV03171 (Los Angeles County Superior Court), punitive damages against a physician were struck from the amended complaint because the plaintiff never obtained the § 425.13 order first. | No count in this data. The exception: Section 425.13 does not apply to elder abuse claims seeking the Elder Abuse Act's own heightened remedies (Covenant Care, Inc. v. Superior Court (2004) 32 Cal.4th 771). |
Procedural and other reasons: 35 rulings, mixed.
Issue 1, the leave split: Of the 214 label strikes, 137 came with leave and 61 without, and 16 were in part.
Issue 2, the rule: Against an entity, § 3294(b) requires tying the conduct to someone in management.
Issue 3, the ignored problem: Note that this complaint described an ignored problem and still lost; detail that reads as carelessness, even repeated carelessness, is not malice. (The unanswered complaints here came after the injury, not as advance warning of the danger. That is a different, weaker pattern than the notice-then-inaction cases below.)
Issue 4, the order requirement: These statutes require court permission before punitive damages can be pleaded against these defendants. Better facts don't fix this one.
Where the average misleads: negligence cases with a warning
| Group | Punitive damages survived |
|---|---|
| All rulings | 327 of 735 (44%) |
| Car-accident, premises and similar negligence cases | 29 of 99 (29%) |
| Negligence cases where the complaint alleged the defendant was told about the danger and did nothing | 14 of 19 (74%) |
| Negligence cases without that allegation | 15 of 80 (19%) |
The lower negligence rate is what you'd expect, since negligence alone can't support punitive damages. Inside that group, one allegation made a large difference.
Two caveats: The negligence group is an approximate grouping built from keywords, not a hand-coded category. And the notice split is an association: the allegation and the outcome go together, but this doesn't show the allegation caused the ruling.
Still, the same lesson as the rest of this data applies here: specific facts beat labels. If you have a warning and a failure to act, plead them in specific terms rather than leaving them implicit.
What this means for you
| If you're pleading | If you're moving to strike |
|---|---|
| Describe the conduct in specific terms (what the defendant knew, when, and what it did about it), and check the other buckets before you file. | Read the complaint for those same things. |
| Against a company, name the manager. | The grounds that most often succeeded: labels with no facts (214 of 215), no managing-agent link (73 of 77), negligence- or contract-only claims (49 of 49), and a skipped gatekeeping order (21 of 21). |
| Against a health care provider, get the § 425.13 order, unless the claim is elder abuse seeking the Act's own heightened remedies, where § 425.13 doesn't apply at all (Covenant Care, Inc. v. Superior Court (2004) 32 Cal.4th 771). | But weigh the payoff: about half of the strikes came with leave to amend. |
| If the underlying claim is only negligence, the label "punitive" won't carry it. | A motion to strike is a pleading-stage ruling, not a preview of the evidence. |
What a strike gets the defendant
| Of the 408 strikes | Rulings |
|---|---|
| With leave to amend | 213 (52%) |
| Without leave to amend | up to 123 (30%) |
| Struck some punitive allegations and left others in | 72 (18%) |
How firm the "without leave" count is: Counted against all 735 rulings, that is up to 17% ending punitive damages at that hearing without leave. The firm number is lower: only 52 of the 123 say "without leave" in the ruling's disposition. The other 71 say so elsewhere in the ruling or are our reading of a final strike. So the range is 7% to 17% of all rulings.
What happens after leave: We can't yet say how often a struck-with-leave claim comes back and survives on the amended complaint; that hasn't been measured.
Methodology note: 735 hearing-level rulings (one per case and hearing date; 698 distinct cases) deciding a defendant's motion to strike punitive damages, drawn from California superior court tentative rulings in seven counties (Los Angeles 529, Orange 118, Contra Costa 31, Riverside 23, Santa Clara 20, San Bernardino 11, San Mateo 3), mostly from May to September 2026. Data as of 2026-10-11. Other California counties, including San Francisco, Alameda, San Diego and Sacramento, are not in the set. "Struck" means the court granted the motion as to punitive allegations; "survived" means the court denied it; "without leave" means leave to amend was denied or the ruling read as a final strike. Each ruling was coded for the court's stated reason by an AI model reading the full ruling. Every quoted disposition was checked against the source text; a hand check of 43 rulings found no wrong-direction outcomes, one in-part versus full-grant mislabel, and two rulings of the wrong motion type, which were then filtered out. In that check, none of the 41 genuine motions to strike had a reason code that contradicted the court's stated reason, and two were borderline two-reason rulings; each code was compared against the verified quote and the model's reason note, not a fresh full read of every ruling. Department was recorded for 613 of the 735 rulings across roughly 100 departments, and no department accounts for more than 3.4% (the largest, 25 rulings). The set counts motions that were actually heard and posted, not every complaint that prays for punitive damages, and those tentatives can change at argument. About 37% of the rulings involve fraud or concealment counts, many of them repeat automaker lemon-law motions, so the overall rate reflects that mix. Case numbers are cited so you can pull the docket; the rulings are non-precedential tentatives. These counts describe the court's stated reason, not a predicted chance of winning. Nothing here is legal advice. Updated 2026-10-12: counts revised after removing duplicate rulings; no conclusion changed. Updated 2026-10-14: wording clarified; numbers unchanged.